Comments for Madhav Desai

Comment on Freedom of Kashmir: Let them go… by ken

ken — Mon, 30 Jan 2012 17:20:39 +0000

“Well I agree with all your points except that Kashmir unite Hindu and Muslims in India”………..

I mean to say united against Pakistan from the position of national strength/regional power

Does India have School Prayer Amendment like this?
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/School_Prayer_Amendment

I don’t see problem with this universal prayer if both Hindu and Muslim can translate/interpret properly with exact meanings without putting religious label on it.So far all Pundits are looking correct meanings.

Paraphrases……….

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gayatri_Mantra

Separate laws govern Hindus, Muslims, Christians, Sikhs, and followers of other religions…………
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Law_of_India

“We should get rid of this tumour in our head.”…………….

This religious tumor in our head is part of Indian life as long as India lives.By getting rid of Kashmir home grown tumor won’t go away.We have to fight this tumor daily by searching new healing medications.

Gujarati India’s state Language or National Script??

Comment on Freedom of Kashmir: Let them go… by Madhav Desai

Madhav Desai — Mon, 30 Jan 2012 13:31:46 +0000

Well I agree with all your points except that Kashmir unite Hindu and Muslims in India. If you see Kashmiri Muslims have asked schools to include Islamic Prayers in their daily routines – imagine what will happen if Hindus ask for Gayatri Mantra to be recited in school.

We should get rid of this tumour in our head. They are highly volatile.

Comment on Freedom of Kashmir: Let them go… by ken

ken — Mon, 30 Jan 2012 00:33:02 +0000

Kashmir is the only issue unites India as whole country with both Hindu and Muslim as people.Both India and Pakistan can keep their controlled area.Give Kashmiris choice where ever they want to live/migrate..Take a look at China how peacefully it controls Tibet by improving people’s livelihood. Even Israel is also slowly moving towards peace with Palestine people.It takes time to heal wounds through strength.One may wait till Baluchistan issue is resolved.

Comment on Freedom of Kashmir: Let them go… by wagjyl

wagjyl — Fri, 06 Jan 2012 10:33:58 +0000

i agree…

please just let kashmir go..

let it be on its own as it was way way before…

Comment on Gandhi & Jinnah: Indian Freedom Movement by Ron Bahai

Ron Bahai — Sat, 27 Aug 2011 05:52:27 +0000

Thanks for your kind attention to this very serious and fundamental issue of
Partition of 1947.
India was one of the largest Exporters in the world until 1947 ,the British planned to divide
The country for many reasons.
1. To stop Indian trade with rest of the world by Road as GT ROAD was the Main Trade Route for India
From Kabul to Calcutta,with creation of a dummy country Pakistan this trade was affected severly and
Many products which used to be exported this route could not be marketed.
2.The number one Trade in the world is military equipments exported by Super powers, so
Now Pakistan and India both spend major part of their budget on defence so the money is siphoned
Back to the Goras again.Corrupt poiticians and Army officials of India and Pakistan earn kick backs and commission worth Millions of dollars .That is the main reason politicans and army dont want PEACE at all.
3.The Modern colonisation is through MULTINATIONAL companies and STOCK EXCHANGES, so
Again the weath of India and Pakistan is being transferred to the western countries through Franchising
Their Multinational giant corporate sector.Can you imagine a local farmer in India has to spend most of
His profit of hard earned money on the multinational products like seeds,Urea,Pesticides even tractors.
That is the main reason of plight of indian farmers.

As for your comments

And about Muslims in Pakistan being Hindu – that is history and it matters no more
Well India and Pakistan are part and parcel of GREAT VEDIC CULTURE of thousands of years
and AS FAR AS I AM CONCERNED any body born in VEDIC LAND is a HINDU by birth.
Jai Hind

Comment on Freedom of Kashmir: Let them go… by Madhav Desai

Madhav Desai — Sat, 20 Aug 2011 20:42:32 +0000

Hmmn, but why should we keep the lot that hate to call themselves Indians.. Plebiscite will only result in sepration – and at the end India will end up with Ladakh and Jammu.

Pakistan will make the same setup in Indian Kashmir as they have done in Pak Kashmir – i.e. Lawlessness and anarchy. How will they feed these people when they are unable to feed people in Peshwar and Rawalpindi? HOw will Kashmiris get CNG and Petrol when there are Rations of Fuel in Islamabad and Lahore?

So let them go and never return is good for India.

Comment on Freedom of Kashmir: Let them go… by kashmir

kashmir — Sat, 20 Aug 2011 19:28:24 +0000

sir
I would like post my honest opinion here that indian goverment should make it easy for kashmirians to visits both sides of kashmir also the passport process and visa system should be mad easy for kashmirians for visiting to pakistan. Families of militants should allowed to meet their relative stayed it POK. when it vl happen once kashmrians would b exposed to real pakistan as they are living in fool’s pardise and they vl come to about realities and come out of their imaginary world. after some time a plebisite should be held i can assure you people that plebiscite will go in the fate of india and this vexing problem vl b sloved and india vl boost up economically as i vl come out of big economical hurdle

Comment on Gandhi & Jinnah: Indian Freedom Movement by Madhav Desai

Madhav Desai — Tue, 12 Jul 2011 09:29:28 +0000

Dear Ron Bahai,

Thank you for your visit from Canada. Well it seems you are a staunch Hindu with fed-in bigoted knowledge of history. Everything in this world cannot be a conspiracy theory and unless you can prove it you have to think of it as otherwise.

I seriously recommend you to read Jinnah’s autobiography where you can easily find that before 1945 he never thought about Pakistan and it was his model of grouping that led him to the idea of Pakistan.

With Nehru and Lady Mountbatten – they were both in Love and thats all what history knows about him. Nehru was never a British Agent – he cannot be one.

Before you advice me of researching I think you need to start Reading. Nehru died many decades back – Indians had all chance of improving how they are governed.

And about Muslims in Pakistan being Hindu – that is history and it matters no more.

Jai Hind.

Comment on Gandhi & Jinnah: Indian Freedom Movement by Ron Bahai

Ron Bahai — Tue, 12 Jul 2011 04:21:34 +0000

Thanks to all India was divided by British Agents.
1. Jinnah was trained in England and acted as a spy to destroy unity among indians. He did not
Follow Islam or any religion ,he was a British *****.
2.Nehru was a British Agent also he officially said he is Hindu only by chance.
He was allowed to sleep with wife of Mountbaiton last Viceroy of India.
How come an Indian freedom fighter was allowed to enter in the bed room of Edwina Mountbaiton
The reason is he was a paid British Agent
Please do research and learn that Indian traitors like Jinnah and Nehru are responsible for the
Plight of common people of Indo o Pak. Religiondoes not teach hate at all
Most of 90% muslims of Indo Pak are Hindu by blood.
Peace Jai Hind

Comment on World War 3, the Concept: Part 1 by Madhav Desai

Madhav Desai — Tue, 28 Jun 2011 15:03:27 +0000

Manish,

Thank you. Wars are not fought in World War out of enemity but out of alliances or strategic interest. If you have read the Fortune Magazine, it predicted that India and Pak forces can attack China in 2030 if China builds a dam on Brahmaputra River.

If you see all recent wars including Kargil war were fought to protect or gain strategic interests.

There are many scenarios where US & Russia can be on one side – if one of the Uranium or Plutonium consignment on its way through Pakistan gets stolen, US and Russia will get together alongwith France and UK to get all Pak’s nuclear assets neutralised.

So these things are never impossible. Germany is part of NATO the same country which was hit bad from the similar alliance.

So concepts will always be concepts – read them on! and forget them! Writers like myself build them only to claim “I said so” when they happen – but chances of these happening are millions to one.

Regards,